Small business owner reviewing S-corp salary paperwork in Logan, Utah

Reasonable Compensation for S-Corps, Explained

Karli Bilskie

5 min

Set your S-corp salary too low and you're looking at back taxes and penalties. Here's what reasonable actually means, and why the split rules you've heard are myths.

If you run an S-corp, reasonable compensation is one of those phrases that sounds boring and turns out to be a very big deal. Get it wrong and you are looking at back taxes and penalties. Get it right and it is one of the cleaner ways an S-corp saves on tax. Here is the plain-English version.

Why S-corps have to think about this

The appeal of an S-corp is that profits you take as distributions are not hit with self-employment tax the way a salary is. That is a real saving. But the IRS knows it too, so it requires owners who work in the business to pay themselves a reasonable salary first, before taking distributions. You cannot pay yourself a tiny salary and run everything else through as a distribution to sidestep the tax.

What counts as reasonable

Reasonable means what you would pay someone else to do the work you actually do. The IRS looks at your role, your experience, the hours you put in, what similar positions pay, and how much the business earns. There is no magic percentage.

You may have heard rules like a 60/40 or 50/50 split between salary and distributions. Those are myths. The number has to be defensible for your specific situation, not pulled from a formula.

Why getting it wrong is expensive

If the IRS decides your salary was too low, it can reclassify your distributions as wages, then charge the payroll taxes you skipped plus penalties and interest. This is one of the most common things they look at on S-corp returns, so it is not a place to guess.

The right way to handle it

The clean approach is to document how you arrived at your number, using real data on comparable pay, and to revisit it as the business changes. Done right, it holds up under scrutiny and it saves you money at the same time.

This is exactly the kind of thing handled in a full written strategy plan, where we set your compensation with the documentation to back it up.

General information, not advice for your business. Your reasonable number depends on your specifics, so let's look at them together.

Have a question I haven't written about yet?

These are the questions I hear most, but yours might not be on the list. If you're wondering how something applies to your situation, that's exactly what a conversation is for. And if you're ready to go further than an article can take you, here's see how the planning works.

Illustrated desk with a computer and open notebook, from the Balancing Bils tax blog
Illustrated desk with a computer and open notebook, from the Balancing Bils tax blog

Contact: (435) 227-5368 | bb@balancingbils.com

Client Portal: balancingbils.taxdome.com/login

Location: Logan, UT | Serving clients virtually nationwide

© 2026 Copyright Balancing Bils LLC

Contact: (435) 227-5368 | bb@balancingbils.com

Client Portal: balancingbils.taxdome.com/login

Location: Logan, UT | Serving clients virtually nationwide

© 2026 Copyright Balancing Bils LLC

Contact: (435) 227-5368 | bb@balancingbils.com

Client Portal: balancingbils.taxdome.com/login

Location: Logan, UT | Serving clients virtually nationwide

© 2026 Copyright Balancing Bils LLC